Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Findings and Trends in the Long-Term Care Insurance Industry

Findings and Trends in the Long-Term Care Insurance Industry

According to information gathered by the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance (AALTCI) in their 2012 LTCi Sourcebook and what occurred in 2013, the LTCi industry continues to evolve and certain buying trends have become apparent.

We’re seeing internal rate increases for new buyers based upon gender based pricing and claims history, rate increases for existing policyholders, the elimination of certain benefits and features; decreases in discounts and stricter underwriting requirements.

This was bound to happen due to the existing economic and regulatory climate.  Interest rates are remaining low. The anticipated 5% policy lapse ratio is actually 1-1.5%. Policyholders are holding onto their policies. They see the value in having the coverage. The top 10 carriers paid $10.8 million in claims per day in 2011. In order for LTCi companies to remain solvent and live up to their obligations, change had to occur.

Last year, the change with the most impact was gender-based pricing. Women live longer, are on claim longer, therefore they will pay more for coverage. The premium increases have been 20% or more depending upon the state. Several states, however, have opted not to approve this trend citing discrimination. Lawsuits are pending.

The questions asked most often by prospective clients are when is the right time to buy and how should the features be designed? 

The average buyer’s age has changed dramatically. Twenty years ago, the average buyer was 70 years old. Today, approximately 56.5% of buyers are between the ages of 55 and 64; 22% are 45 to 54 and 18% are 65 and over. It seems that more individuals are planning for LTC prior to retirement when the premiums are lower and insurability is higher.

According to the 2012 LTCi Sourcebook, approximately 46.5% of couples bought policies together versus 21.5% of sales for singles. Perhaps due to cost or insurability, 32% of sales were for one spouse.

On the national level, the average daily benefit selected was between $150-199, the average length of coverage was 3 years, and the average elimination period was 90 to 100 days. In terms of inflation, 5% compound was chosen more often with 3% compound as the second most popular choice. Very few individuals purchase CPI based inflation or Future Purchase Options.

According to a 5 year study conducted by John Hancock on costs of care, nursing homes averaged a 3.5% increase, assisted living 3.4% and home care 1.5%. Depending upon  age, selecting 3.5% inflation could stay in line with future costs and save premium dollars especially if a higher daily benefit is initially selected to compensate for the lower inflation protection.

In CNY, the average cost of nursing home care is $350 so the selected daily benefit would be higher than the national norm. In NYS, the Partnership plans have a minimum daily benefit of $274 for 2014 as well as mandated coverage periods and inflation options.

The LTCi companies have gathered extensive claim statistics over the last 35 years. According to the LTCi Sourcebook, 50% of newly opened claims are paid for home care; 19% for assisted living and 31% for nursing home care. 65.5% of claims start at age 80 or older; 24.1% at ages 70 to 79; and 8.4% at ages 60-69.

As far as marketing trends, we are seeing more policies with alternative cash benefits and more hybrid policies (life insurance with LTC or chronic illness riders)

Cash alternative benefits add flexibility at claim time. It allows policyholders to pay for informal care from friends and neighbors who generally cost less thereby extending the life of the policy. This feature also takes into consideration future caregiving options.

The hybrid policies allow for the acceleration of the death benefit to pay for LTC expenses. Those with LTC riders generally require a single premium and two sets of underwriting. Many of the features in the LTC rider are as robust as a standalone LTCi policy. The hybrids with chronic illness riders are a good alternative for individuals who are uninsurable for LTCi because only life underwriting is required. Hybrid policies are appealing because there are no wasted premiums.

More than ever before, individuals have the ability to tailor their LTC plan for affordability and value. Perfect policies don’t exist but the LTCi carriers are offering more appropriate and realistic choices based on statistical information.


Susan Suben, MS, CSA, is President of Long Term Care Associates, Inc. and a consultant for Canandaigua National Bank & Trust Company.  Information for this article was gathered from the AALTC 2012 Sourcebook and ICB 2013 Webinar on LTC Trends. She can be reached at 800-422-2655 or by email at susansuben@31greenbush.com. 

Wednesday, January 8, 2014

 INSURANCE CHECKLIST FOR 2014

Insurance is purchased for many reasons. The primary one is to transfer risk. Life insurance provides a tax-free death benefit to heirs to pay off debt or replace lost income. Disability insurance is designed to replace lost income in the event of an accident or illness. Long-term care insurance helps pay for services and settings when a long-term illness occurs. If you acquired any of these products as part of your financial or retirement plan, it’s important to review the features periodically to determine if your original need for the coverage still exists and if the product is performing the way you expected it to. Following are some questions that will help you review your coverage.

Life Insurance

1. What type of life insurance do you own? Is it term or permanent (universal or whole Life) insurance?

2. What is your death benefit?

3. If you have a whole life policy, what is your cash surrender value?

4. What is your premium? How long is it guaranteed for?

5. Are your beneficiaries up to date?

6. Have you paid off the debt or fulfilled the obligations you originally purchased the coverage for? Your life circumstances may have changed and you may no longer need the coverage.

7. Would it be practical to exchange your current life policy for a life insurance policy with long-term care or chronic illness rider through a 1035 exchange as allowed through the Pension Protection Act?

8. If you have a life insurance policy with cash value, do you know that you can use some of that cash value to pay for a long-term care insurance premium tax-free?

Long-Term Care Insurance

1. Do you own a partnership or non-partnership plan? A partnership plan would provide total or partial asset protection in NYS if you exhaust your benefits and still need care. Once you exhaust your benefits, you are also able to apply for Medicaid without any look-back period for gifting.

2. If you have a non-partnership plan, is it based on a reimbursement or cash/indemnity payment model? A reimbursement plan would pay up to your daily/monthly benefit for actual expenses while a cash/indemnity plan would pay your full benefit regardless of the actual cost of care.

3. Do you have inflation protection? If so, how has your daily/monthly benefit grown?

4. Is your daily/monthly benefit keeping pace with the cost of care in your area? Do you need to supplement your benefit?

5. What are the triggers to receive benefits? Some older policies require you to be unable to perform 2 out of 5 activities of daily living as opposed to 2 out of 6 for the newer plans. Bathing was often missing as a trigger.

6. Does your home care benefit allow you to use independent caregivers or unskilled/unlicensed caregivers as opposed to only an agency?

7. Did you assign a third party to receive notification if you forget to pay your premium? Countless policies lapse because a premium has not been paid.

8. Are you aware that there is a 20% NYS tax credit on your premium if your policy is tax-qualified? Since 1997, most long-term care insurance policies are tax-qualified.

Disability Insurance

1. Do you have short-term or long-term disability?

2. Does the policy provide own occupation protection? Own occupation protection means that you have to be unable to perform the duties of your occupation as opposed to a policy that guarantees to pay benefits if you are unable to work at all.

3. What is you maximum monthly benefit?

4. Can you increase your benefit?

5. Are your benefits adjusted for inflation?

6. How long will your benefit be paid?

7. How is your disability determined?

8. How long do you have to wait to receive benefits?

9. Is the policy guaranteed renewable? Your policy will stay in force but the premiums may increase.

10. Can you receive partial benefits if you go back to work part-time?

11. What are the exclusions?

Insurance provides protection for you and your family against certain risks. However, needs and goals change and consequently so does your risk exposure. You should review your insurance policies at least every three to five years to make certain you understand your coverage and if it has retained its value. Set a goal to meet with your insurance agent in 2014.

Susan Suben, MS, CSA, is President of Long Term Care Associates, Inc. and Elder Care Planning. She can be reached at 800-422-2655 or by email at susansuben@31greenbush.com.